Throwaways – Mascara

Hi guys:) Welcome back. Today, I’ll be talking about mascaras. This post has been awhile in the making, coz I have things piling up on every corner. This will be my last post for awhile – I wanted to do a movie review of Age of Ultron, but it’s going into the backburner since I am (a)under-qualified as a movie reviewer (b)there’s too much I want to say and too little time to say it all. Eventually, I am going to write it, it’s just not going up any time soon.

Okay, so recently I bought the L’Oreal Voluminous Miss Manga Mascara. It was its first introduction into the stores, so there was an introductory price for it. I believe it was about SGD19.90. It has a cone-shaped, curved brush, not unlike many curling mascaras like the Maybelline HyperCurl Volum’ Mascara (shown below). I believe it’s to replace the need for a eyelash curler, but IMHO why would there be an eyelash curler, if there was no need for it?

As the name states, this is a volumizing mascara. It takes awhile to build any sort of length, which I tried because I thought it was like the Maybellines, which I found could basically do it all (with the help of a lash curler, of course) even if they claim to only be volumizing or curling. Nope. It is very capable for volumizing, but a little iffy on the lengthening properties. For that, I do not recommend this mascara to anyone with short lashes (basically, when lashes look like beard stubble). 

I bought this mascara because I was looking for a replacement mascara for my Maybelline mascaras. I bought the Big Eye mascara with its introductory price (SGD17.90 compared to SGD21.90), which came with its own eyelash curler. I highly recommend the eyelash curler, since it’s lightweight and has a flatter curve compared to others, which is very suitable for anyone with flat lids. It sounds really weird, but it works. The Big Eye mascara was a meh for me. It’s nice, but for someone who has chronic droopy lashes, the washable volumizing mascara they created for the upper lash (the pink side of the top mascara), it does not hold my lashes up.

It also makes my eyeballs sting and water with the formula. I think it’s gone bad, but sometimes my eyes are not affected, and sometimes I can’t even get the brush within a mile of it. I have the same problem with the Maybelline HyperCurl Volum’ Express Mascara (the black tube with pink letterings).

The Maybelline HyperCurl is in its old packaging. I bought it almost two years ago, at duty-free cosmetics. It came in a set of threes, and was on discount. I loved the first tube, which lengthened, volumizing and curled my lashes. I was really sad when I had to throw it away after six months since the chemicals were setting my lids on fire.’
I didn’t start using the second tube until this year, since I was sucked into the Jennifer Lawrence Dior ad, where she had no mascara on (Shocker!). I quit my mascaras cold-turkey, and didn’t look back until recently. I just like the way a beautiful curled, lengthened and volumizing lash line finishes a look, or how it can hold up on its own.

But the second tube had none of the magical qualities of the first. And I’m trying to save my money, which does not help my sudden need for mascara. So here’s one last look at the two, before I throw them out.

Bare lashes.

This picture above shows the before and after of the Maybelline HyperCurl. Excuse the red eye, I believe I was reading for too long on my phone, and forgot to rest them. I did curl my lashes in the before, so you can get a gauge of my natural lashes. It looks much longer in the after, defined and a bit of volume, but if you’d seen the magic of the first tube, you might think this is okay. It’s also a pain to remove (which I forgot after a year of no mascara).

My right eye (yes, that is my eye) is wearing the Big Eye Mascara. I really like the waterproof formula and brush. It reminds me of the Innisfree Skinny Mascara (although the Innisfree one is much smaller and about SGD13.00), since it not so much as creates a fuller, longer lash than tint and make it look more present. It was for the lower lashes, but I find they do not work that well for me.

The far left picture is the curled lash, and the before mascara. The middle one is the effect of the washable volumizing formula. As you can see, it lengthens quite a fair bit, and volumizes a whole lot. The last one on the right is with the addition of the waterproof formula. The two formulas (waterproof and washable) do not mix well, and it’s a hassle to remove. I’m not even going to keep it for sentimental value.

So here’s the final conclusion on all three mentioned mascara.

L’Oreal Voluminous Miss Manga Mascara

– Lives up to the name; very volumizing
– Has a tiny bit of lengthening, but needs to be carefully done or it becomes spider lashes.
– Very waterproof and also smudgeproof (lasts for the entire day)
– Fast drying

– Very drying (due to the waxes necessary for the waterproof formula)
– Very hard to remove (I had to scrub my lashes to remove it after using a Q-Tip)
– Expensive in Singapore (Price is SGD21.90)

Maybelline Volum’ Express HyperCurl Waterproof Mascara

– Waterproof
– Surprisingly good for lengthening, despite being touted as a volumizing mascara
– Cheapest of the lot (SGD16.90)
– Fast Drying

– Chemicals sting my eye
– Hard to remove

Maybelline Big Eye Mascara

– The upper lash formula is washable with water, and has minimal smudging
– lower lash formula is waterproof and lives up to it
– Lower lash formula dries fast

– Washable formula needs time to dry
– Washable formula makes thin lashes droop
– Chemicals sting the eye
– Cannot mix the two formulas; the result is nice but the hardest to remove and also risks getting the formula into the eye
– Price is SGD21.90

Here’s everything I want to say about my throwaway mascaras. If anyone know how long you can keep unopened mascara, drop a comment below:) Thanks and bye!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s